The NEW YORK DAILY NEWS is sponsoring a contest to come up with an appropriate name for the Manning to Tyree play:
http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/footb all/giants/2008/02/08/2008-02-08_fantast ic_keep_flinging_names_for_david_.html
Can't say I'm in love with any of the suggestions so far, most of which strike me as too labored, but there's still time left, maybe something will emerge.
http://www.nydailynews.com/sports/footb
Can't say I'm in love with any of the suggestions so far, most of which strike me as too labored, but there's still time left, maybe something will emerge.

Comments
But it seems to me that you want to reference both elements - Eli's Houdini-like escape AND the helmet assisted catch.
I'm weak and slow, nothing is really hitting me. Will chew on it a bit...
Let a guy heal a bit.
How's that comedic question go?
What, too soon?
I know, I know, it's mostly about Manning, but it also speaks more broadly of the Giants escaping defeat.
For me it doesn't need a name. Most of the "names" were coined immediately or within a few hours. Any name made up now would be a contrivance.
However, if you must have a name "The Great Escape" works. Had Eli been sacked, they would had to have called their last time out. It would have been 4th and 5 on the Giants 43 with only about 60-65 seconds left. Had Tyree dropped the ball, it would have have left 66-67 seconds left and the clock would have started as soon as the referee started placed the ball and started the play.
Had Manning been sacked it would have been 4th and long on the 37 with no timeouts and 60-65 secs left.
The above comment is 0 (zero) No! But you would say Oh! No!
As in:
( Giant's Fan )Oh! No! Eli is going to get sacked!
( Pat's Fan )Oh! No! He escaped!
( Giant's Fan )Oh! No! He's going to drop it!
( Pat's Fan ) Oh! No! He caught it!
( Pat's Fan ) Oh! No! We lost our O...
"18-1"
THE SCUD! It got right past the Patriots.
Eli escaped the defenders clutch
Tyree Clutched it against his helmet
A clutch play
Heard that one suggested on the radio and really liked it.
Too long, but it covers both sides depending on how you interpret it.
But, for all of us NE Pats fans it will probably always be known as THE PLAY.
And, "the immaculate reception" has nothing to do with being clean, its a play on the "the immaculate conception" the virgin birth, in case you didn't know (though most of you prolly did).
"The Play" is already taken, the Cal-Stanford crazy ending, and if you don't know what that is then you're not a real football fan.
Actually, if I can be a Catholic nerd for a second, the Immaculate Conception refers to the conception of Mary, the mother of Jesus, as she is believed to have been conceived without original sin. (But her parents conceived her by having sex.)
As to the original point of the post, I'm voting for "Slip and Grip."
But I agree, anything they come up with now will just be a contrivance. It's almost passed the point of being talked about. I shudder to think if this sort of thing was happening 30 years ago for the 'Miracle On Ice'. Team USA defeats Russia, and NBC asks bloggers to name the upset:
NBC wants to know what to name the game! Was it:
A) AwesomeGate - 1980
B) Ivan Eats It
C) Miracle On Ice
D) Lake Flacid
E) What's Hockey?