Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

A Few Last Words

I've just locked the comments section of the previous post. We've had about four hundred comments since the post went up last night, and the whole thing is about to collapse under its own weight. I suspect that someone or other has already said everything that can be said on the subject, so now we're starting to go around in circles.

Also, with this many comments, it's becoming obvious that some of the later commenters aren't actually reading what went before. I'm starting to get asked the same questions over and over again -- what about Suvudu? what about the Vance book? what about fan art? what about role-playing games? All fair enough questions, but I have answered all of them in responses to earlier comments. Some I have answered two or three times by now. I am not going to answer them four, five, six, or twelve times, sorry. So if you've posted a question that has already been asked and answered, your post will likely be ignored or deleted. (Yes, I know it's a pain to have to read four hundred comments. Tough. If I have to read them all, so do you. That's the price of taking part in the discussion).

Some comments haven't been unscreened yet. There have been so many of them coming in so fast that it has been hard to keep up. A few have been buried by now, especially comments on comments on comments. Ty or I will get to all of them eventually, I hope, and everything will either be unscreened or deleted.

I want to thank ninety-five percent of the people who took the time to comment. I appreciate your thoughts, and even more, I appreciate the relative calm and thoughtful tone of this discussion, which never degenerated into the kind of ugliness I've seen (and am still seeing) in the comments over on Diana Gabaldon's blog, where the discussion has long since been derailed. I don't know how many minds were changed here, but all the major issues were thoroughly aired, it seems to me, and I hope this generated more light than heat.

There were a few issues raised during the debate that I'd like to address a bit further.

A number of commenters suggested that I was wrong in my assertion that copyrights need to be defended, and suggested that I was confusing copyrights with trademarks. Perhaps so. This was raised often enough that it is obviously something I need to look into further. There were also posters who agreed with what I wrote, however, including some who identified themselves as lawyers or law students, so I don't think the issue is as clear cut as the "trademark" folks are claiming. I'll investigate this, and if I was wrong about this, I will come back here and say so (eventually, this is not my top priority in life). If I was right, I'll come back and mention that as well.

ERB v HPL. I never said that allowing others to play with the Cthulhu mythos was the ONLY reason Lovecraft died in poverty. Actually, I am a huge Lovecraft fan, and not much of a Burroughs fan at all (though Melinda Snodgrass and I did once work on the screenplay for A PRINCESS OF MARS). I know a lot about HPL. His work has been hugely influential on modern horror. But my point stands. I could write a Cthulhu Mythos novel tomorrow, and I would not have to pay a dime to any Lovecraft estate (if such exists) or get their permission. I would never dare write a Barsoom novel, though surely PRINCESS is in the public domain by now. (The later John Carter and Tarzan novels may still be under copyright).

A few people have quoted or posted links to the other side of the Marion Zimmer Bradley incident, the account of the fan involved. Fine, two sides to every story, check it out. At this point, twenty years after the fact, it all becomes she said/ she said. But the version I posted was hardly "urban legend," as one commenter called it. It was the version given by Marion Zimmer Bradley herself in SFWA FORUM, what she told the rest of the writing community. If you want to believe she lied, well, that's your prerogative.

More thoughts as I have 'em. Just now, I have work to do.


May. 10th, 2010 05:23 am (UTC)
In response to dreamflower02...
Your response to my post is well laid out, and certainly passionate. You lead off by saying that I've made some assumptions, and I agree that I probably have. If you'll indulge me, I'd like to point out a few of your own.

First, I'm not criticizing a culture. I'm criticizing the practice of writing fanfic. Fanfic creators are also members of fandom, which is a culture. I'm also a fan and I feel very passionate about the authors I'm a fan of. Trust me, I wouldn't want to write my own stories if I felt otherwise. And by the way, it's not about the money for me either. Your assumption that people who write original works of fiction for money is a little silly given the incredible odds it takes for someone to be as successful as a best-selling author.

If fanfiction has given life to new literary forms, I think that's wonderful. But we don't need fanfic to do that. Fanfic didn't create the haiku or essay.

You are correct in that world building and character creation are not critical to writing. I can write a song, or a letter to an editor and have no use for those tools. However, world building and character creation are in fact, the central element in creating works of fiction. The words of a story form its body, but the world and the characters in it give that story a soul.

Of all of your points, I find the notion that writing fanfic is more difficult than original works dubious at best. JRR Tolkien invented several languages, thousands of years of history, and a pantheon of gods before he wrote the Hobbit or Lord of the Rings. Do you honestly think that writing a derivative work in his Middle Earth is harder than that? Did I mention he did all of that while fighting in World War I? I have no doubt that many people have written 'great' fanfic using Middle Earth, because it is easy to touch the clouds while standing on the shoulders of a literary titan.

I think what disappoints me most of all is the sense that fanfic writers feel entitled to create their works because their love of the subject matter is so great. You may love someone's house, but that doesn't give anyone the right to go in and rearrange the furniture however they like, especially when they ask you not to.
May. 10th, 2010 06:24 am (UTC)
Re: In response to dreamflower02...
"I find the notion that writing fanfic is more difficult than original works dubious at best. "

Firstly, writing difficulty is a spectrum; there are original works that definitely require a lot of time and effort to create, but there are also those that require next to none. And the same goes for fan fiction (I took five years to perfect one particular fanfic novel).

I know from personal experience that I've spent much time agonising over situations in fanfic I'd written myself into that seemed unsolvable due to the constraints of the universe and the character's personalities. For example, if there was a problem in the narrative which would be easily solved by the character turning into a saucepan, this would be easy to enable in original fiction - just make the character in question into a shapeshifter. But if it was, say, a Harry Potter fanfic and the character in question was Ron Weasley, then he has never been able to turn into a saucepan and there is no reason why he should suddenly have this ability. So I'd have to find another way to solve that, and that's where the additional effort comes in.

"I have no doubt that many people have written 'great' fanfic using Middle Earth, because it is easy to touch the clouds while standing on the shoulders of a literary titan."

But there are also people who have written terrible fanfic using Middle Earth. Here's an impromptu example:

"1 dae legilas and aragggon were runnin about wheeee wen suddnly they were nakid and died from munsters lol."

Standing on the shoulders of a literary titan didn't seem to help in that case, and I would think that would indicate that the fanfic writer's own skill does matter when it comes to the quality of a fanfic. Also, when people speak of great fanfic, they mean just that - great fanfic. It's not meant as a comparison to non-fanfic works, and can't be compared, because they're completely different genres of writing.

"You may love someone's house, but that doesn't give anyone the right to go in and rearrange the furniture however they like, especially when they ask you not to."

Interestingly, someone used a similar analogy over at Diana Gabaldon's blog, which I think was more accurate than yours: Say that you decorate your house in a certain way and invite people in to look at it. Then they go home and, inspired, decorate their own houses in a similar way, but making occasional changes here and there to give it their own personal touch; and then they hang a sign on the wall saying that the decoration was based off yours. Your own house remains unaffected. And what a lot of anti-fanfic writers are basically saying is that, no, those people should not be allowed to decorate their houses in a similar way.
May. 10th, 2010 01:31 pm (UTC)
Re: In response to dreamflower02...
Thank you! You made exactly the points I had planned to make, right down to the house-decorating analogy.

In addition, there is this, so far as regards J.R.R. Tolkien: his world and universe is the only one I write fanfic in. He actually at one point expressed the hope that other minds and hands would use the mythology and legends he created. So we have the Great Man's express permission to do so.

Some people who come and play in his sandbox are not very skillful, but they still love the sandbox, and they are immensely grateful to him for building it and giving it to them to use.

Finally, I said that there were *some things* about fanfic that were more difficult. Certainly world-building and character creation are difficult. Yet you also have to realize that a certain amount of that also enters in to fanfic. For example, JRRT never described the lands to the East of Mordor, so any fanfic involving those unexplored areas of Arda most certainly call for a bit of sub-sub-creation. The same thing goes when an Original Character is called for in a fanfiction, or when that fanfiction calls for a minor character who was little more than a name in canon needs to be fleshed out.

Fanfiction IS a genre of its own, with its own rules and guidelines. And those can be more challenging in many ways.


George R.R. Martin
George R. R. Martin

Latest Month

April 2018


Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Lilia Ahner